35 by 35 at COP31: Three caveats for electrification

Ana Díaz-Vidal

The COP31 Presidency’s proposal will only be effective if it prioritises reducing energy demand, requires renewable electricity and distributes the burden fairly.

This week in Antalya, the COP31 Presidency called on governments to commit to the 35 by 35 target. The proposal aims to increase electricity’s share of global final energy consumption from just under a quarter to 35% by 2035. Even the conference president acknowledges that current trends will not be enough to achieve this, although the International Energy Agency (IEA) considers the target feasible. Spain has endorsed the proposal with a qualification that its Ministry for the Ecological Transition has been reiterating in recent days: electrification must replace coal, oil and gas, not prolong their use.

Spain has an additional reason to be demanding. Its National Energy and Climate Plan already sets a target of 35% electrification by 2030, five years ahead of the global deadline, alongside targets for 81% renewable electricity and a 48% share of renewables in final energy consumption. Signing up to 35 by 35 would therefore ask Spain to do nothing it has not already committed to. The question is not whether it should support the target, but under what conditions.

Following COP28, we argued that a target measured in gigawatts, such as the pledge to triple installed renewable capacity, overlooked the problem of fossil fuel consumption. The 35 by 35 target risks repeating that mistake. This article outlines three caveats Spain should insist on, and which must be written into the commitment itself rather than left to countries’ goodwill.

First, reduce energy demand

The proposed 35% electrification target is a fraction, and its ratio can be increased in two ways: by generating more electricity or by consuming less energy. The second route is always faster. Yet the discussion in Antalya has focused almost entirely on consuming more electricity — more transmission infrastructure, more storage, more gigawatts — while paying little attention to the other side of the equation: the fossil energy we burn in harmful sectors. Indeed, estimates suggest that only a quarter of final energy consumption in the Global North goes towards essential production.

The same pattern is repeating itself. Since COP28, renewable energy capacity has continued to grow at a record pace, but its share of the energy we actually consume has increased only slowly, because demand has continued to grow even faster. Expanding installed capacity is not enough if we consume more every year. If the goal is to increase electricity’s share of final energy, the most direct route is to reduce the fossil component of the denominator. Avoiding energy consumption, rather than adding new capacity, should be the primary means of getting there.

So which forms of consumption need to decline? The IPCC has made clear that the greatest potential for avoiding emissions lies in addressing the consumption of a small share of the highest-emitting households, which account for a disproportionate share of consumption-based emissions. Other important levers include directing production towards meeting basic needs, reducing long-haul aviation and designing cities so that people can walk, cycle and use public transport. The agroecological transition and ecosystem restoration also have a crucial role to play. Ending public support that keeps fossil fuels artificially cheap — amounting to trillions of dollars a year when indirect support is included — is an obvious step, although it must be carried out in line with the principles of a just transition.

The COP31 Presidency’s proposal should therefore include efforts to reduce absolute energy consumption, with a particular focus on fossil fuels, alongside efforts to increase electricity’s share of final energy.

Second, renewable electricity: shifting emissions is not enough

Electrification without renewables simply shifts emissions from the tailpipe to the power plant. The data show just how true this is. According to REN21’s new Renewables-Based Economy Tracker, which draws on IEA data for 128 countries, only eight already derive at least 35% of their final energy consumption from electricity. Across the sample as a whole, the relationship between electrification and renewable energy is surprisingly weak. A commitment that counts electrons without considering their source could therefore be met by countries that have barely begun their transition to renewables.

In Spain, more than half of electricity generation is already renewable, and the country has been a net electricity exporter for four consecutive years. Yet electricity still accounts for only around a quarter of final energy consumption, well below the 35% target set by its own national plan for 2030. Unlike the global proposal, Spain’s target is already explicitly linked to a requirement that 81% of electricity be renewable.

Globally, although wind and solar met almost all the growth in electricity demand in 2025, nearly six out of every ten units of electricity are still generated from fossil fuels.

This brings us to the second caveat: only renewable electricity should count towards the 35% target. Critics have already pointed out that, as currently worded, the commitment does not require additional electricity to come from renewable sources.

Third, unequal starting points: solidarity is not optional

Of the 128 countries covered by REN21’s renewable energy tracker, twenty obtain less than 10% of their final energy from electricity, and seventeen of these are in sub-Saharan Africa. Worldwide, 655 million people still lack access to electricity, most of them in this region. For these countries, electrification is not about replacing existing energy sources, but about gaining access to energy in the first place. In some cases, their main obstacle is not a lack of solar or wind potential, but a lack of financing. Ethiopia, which will host COP32, already generates all its electricity from renewables. Yet electricity accounts for just 3% of its final energy consumption.

Funding is nowhere near sufficient. International public finance for clean energy in developing countries remains inadequate, fell in 2025, and is provided mainly in the form of loans rather than grants. The EU has said it will maintain its existing climate finance target for 2035, but has made no new pledges. A global target that fails to account for countries’ different starting points will reproduce existing inequalities.

This is where countries with an advantage can demonstrate what leadership actually means. Spain pledged in Seville to allocate 0.7% of its gross national income to development assistance by 2030, and has announced hundreds of millions of euros for climate action. These are real commitments, but modest ones. A fair commitment would ask countries with clean electricity grids and greater financial capacity to go beyond 35% or reach the target sooner — as Spain aims to do by 2030 — while allowing differentiated targets that prioritise access to energy and opening up a dedicated funding window based on grants, not just loans.

Conclusion

The 35% target is clearly an indicator. But it is one that does not distinguish between coal and solar power, rewards growing energy demand and ignores countries’ different starting points. Spain is in a position to insist on these caveats: it has a national 35% target for 2030 that is renewable by design, as well as a track record of international cooperation. But if we are to turn 35 by 35 into an ambitious commitment, we must prioritise reducing fossil fuel demand, require new electricity to come from renewable sources, and match ambition with robust mechanisms for solidarity.


The opinions expressed in the text do not necessarily reflect those of R&Di, but are those of the author.


About the author
Ana Díaz-Vidal is a predoctoral researcher at the University of Barcelona, ​​part of the European project “Models, Assessments and Policies for Sustainability,” and a member of Research and Degrowth.